| Most Goals in a Game |
| Goals | Player | Opponent | Game |
| 14 | John Coleman | Fitzroy | R7, 1954, Windy Hill |
| 13.4 | Matthew Lloyd | Sydney | R3, 1999, M.C.G. |
| 13 | John Coleman | Geelong | R8, 1952, Brisbane Exhibition |
| 13 | John Coleman | Hawthorn | R18, 1952, Windy Hill |
| 12 | Fred Gallagher | Geelong | R8, 1957, Windy Hill |
| 12 | John Coleman | Hawthorn | R1, 1949, Windy Hill |
| 12 | Ted Freyer | Melbourne | R1, 1935, M.C.G. |
| 11.4 | Paul Salmon | Richmond | R19, 1986, Waverley Park |
| 11.3 | Paul Salmon | West Coast | R15, 1987, W.A.C.A. |
| 11.3 | Geoff Blethyn | Footscray | R12, 1972, Windy Hill |
| 11.1 | Matthew Lloyd | Western Bulldogs | R19, 2003, Docklands |
| 11 | John Coleman | South Melbourne | R2, 1953, Lake Oval |
| 11 | John Coleman | South Melbourne | R2, 1950, Windy Hill |
| 10.6 | Paul Salmon | Geelong | R6, 1993, M.C.G. |
| 10.4 | Matthew Lloyd | West Coast | R6, 2001, Docklands |
| 10.4 | Ted Fordham | Collingwood | R14, 1966, Victoria Park |
| 10 | Ron Evans | Hawthorn | R12, 1960, Glenferrie Oval |
| 10 | John Coleman | Hawthorn | R1, 1954, Glenferrie Oval |
| 10 | John Coleman | Fitzroy | R1, 1953, Windy Hill |
| 10 | John Coleman | St Kilda | R3, 1953, Windy Hill |
| 10 | John Coleman | Richmond | R18, 1953, Punt Rd |
| 10 | John Coleman | Collingwood | R11, 1950, Windy Hill |
| 10 | John Coleman | St Kilda | R18, 1950, Junction Oval |
| 10 | Tom Reynolds | Hawthorn | R10, 1939, Windy Hill |
| 10 | Vince Irwin | St Kilda | R8, 1924, Windy Hill |
| 10 | Greg Stockdale | St Kilda | R1, 1923, Windy Hill |
[