| Most Goals in a Game |
| Goals | Player | Opponent | Game |
| 14 | Doug Strang | North Melbourne | R2, 1931, Punt Rd |
| 12 | Jack Baggott | South Melbourne | R9, 1928, Punt Rd |
| 11.3 | Michael Roach | Hawthorn | R5, 1985, Princes Park |
| 11.2 | Jack Riewoldt | Greater Western Sydney | R10, 2014, Sydney Showground |
| 11.2 | Michael Roach | Footscray | R7, 1980, Western Oval |
| 10.6 | Jack Riewoldt | Gold Coast | R21, 2018, Carrara |
| 10.4 | Michael Roach | St Kilda | R16, 1980, S.C.G. |
| 10.3 | Jack Riewoldt | West Coast | R12, 2010, M.C.G. |
| 10.3 | Matthew Richardson | Western Bulldogs | R8, 2004, M.C.G. |
| 10.3 | Brian Taylor | Fitzroy | R12, 1982, M.C.G. |
| 10.2 | Michael Roach | St Kilda | R18, 1979, Waverley Park |
| 10.1 | Jeff Hogg | Collingwood | R8, 1991, M.C.G. |
| 10.0 | Michael Roach | Footscray | R18, 1980, Waverley Park |
| 10 | Sel Murray | Carlton | R7, 1945, Princes Park |
| 10 | Dick Harris | Essendon | R3, 1944, Windy Hill |
| 10 | Jack Titus | Collingwood | R3, 1942, Punt Rd |
| 10 | Jack Titus | Hawthorn | R6, 1941, Punt Rd |
| 10 | Jack Titus | Footscray | R10, 1936, Western Oval |
| 10 | Doug Strang | North Melbourne | R13, 1933, Arden St |
| 9.5 | Matthew Richardson | Essendon | R21, 2006, M.C.G. |
| 9.2 | Mark Lee | St Kilda | R17, 1982, M.C.G. |
| 9.2 | Michael Roach | South Melbourne | R2, 1981, Lake Oval |
| 9.2 | Barry Richardson | Essendon | R3, 1972, M.C.G. |
| 9.1 | Michael Roach | Hawthorn | R16, 1981, Princes Park |
| 9.1 | Michael Roach | Melbourne | R20, 1980, M.C.G. |
| 9.0 | Jeff Hogg | Fitzroy | R22, 1988, M.C.G. |
| 9 | Jack Dyer | Essendon | PF, 1944, Junction Oval |
| 9 | Jack Titus | St Kilda | R17, 1940, Junction Oval |
| 9 | Jack Titus | North Melbourne | R1, 1938, Punt Rd |
| 9 | Jack Titus | Carlton | R4, 1936, Princes Park |
| 9 | Doug Strang | Hawthorn | R16, 1932, Glenferrie Oval |
| 9 | Jack Titus | Essendon | R17, 1928, Punt Rd |
[