| Most Goals in a Game |
| Goals | Player | Opponent | Game |
| 14.2 | John Longmire | Melbourne | R14, 1990, M.C.G. |
| 12.5 | John Longmire | Richmond | R2, 1990, M.C.G. |
| 11.6 | Malcolm Blight | Footscray | R17, 1981, Western Oval |
| 11.2 | Wayne Carey | Melbourne | R17, 1996, M.C.G. |
| 11 | Jock Spencer | South Melbourne | R16, 1950, Lake Oval |
| 10.6 | Adrian McAdam | Sydney | R6, 1993, Princes Park |
| 10.5 | Wayne Carey | Essendon | R17, 1999, M.C.G. |
| 10.3 | Sam Kekovich | South Melbourne | R12, 1974, Arden St |
| 10.2 | Kerry Good | Melbourne | R20, 1981, Arden St |
| 10.1 | Ben Brown | Port Adelaide | R22, 2019, Docklands |
| 10.0 | Ross Glendinning | Melbourne | R9, 1979, M.C.G. |
| 10 | Jock Spencer | South Melbourne | R15, 1951, Lake Oval |
| 9.5 | John Longmire | Richmond | R14, 1991, M.C.G. |
| 9.5 | Kerry Good | Melbourne | R10, 1981, Waverley Park |
| 9.4 | John Longmire | Sydney | R6, 1993, Princes Park |
| 9.3 | Nick Larkey | Gold Coast | R24, 2023, Bellerive Oval |
| 9.3 | Wayne Carey | Geelong | R16, 1999, S.C.G. |
| 9.2 | Adrian McAdam | Collingwood | R10, 1993, Victoria Park |
| 9.2 | Darryl Sutton | St Kilda | R11, 1980, Moorabbin Oval |
| 9 | Jock Spencer | Carlton | R2, 1950, Princes Park |
| 9 | Syd Dyer | Hawthorn | R6, 1944, Arden St |
| 9 | Sel Murray | Footscray | R10, 1939, Arden St |
| 9 | Sel Murray | Collingwood | R17, 1938, Victoria Park |
| 9 | Frank Crapper | St Kilda | R6, 1936, Junction Oval |
[