| Most Goals in a Game |
| Goals | Player | Opponent | Game |
| 17.5 | Jason Dunstall | Richmond | R7, 1992, Waverley Park |
| 16.1 | Peter Hudson | Melbourne | R5, 1969, Glenferrie Oval |
| 14.2 | Jason Dunstall | Footscray | R19, 1996, Waverley Park |
| 13.4 | Lance Franklin | North Melbourne | R10, 2012, York Park |
| 13.2 | Peter Hudson | South Melbourne | R8, 1970, Glenferrie Oval |
| 13.2 | Peter Hudson | South Melbourne | R11, 1969, Glenferrie Oval |
| 12.8 | Jason Dunstall | Essendon | R20, 1992, M.C.G. |
| 12.6 | Jason Dunstall | Richmond | R22, 1992, M.C.G. |
| 12.4 | Jason Dunstall | Geelong | R1, 1992, Waverley Park |
| 12.4 | Jason Dunstall | Geelong | R1, 1990, Waverley Park |
| 12.2 | Peter Hudson | Footscray | R14, 1968, Glenferrie Oval |
| 12.0 | Peter Hudson | St Kilda | R15, 1971, Glenferrie Oval |
| 11.5 | Jason Dunstall | Brisbane Bears | R12, 1987, Carrara |
| 11.3 | Jason Dunstall | Sydney | R12, 1994, S.C.G. |
| 11.3 | Jason Dunstall | St Kilda | R22, 1989, Waverley Park |
| 11.3 | Leigh Matthews | Essendon | R3, 1973, Waverley Park |
| 11.2 | Dermott Brereton | Richmond | R16, 1990, M.C.G. |
| 11.2 | Jason Dunstall | Collingwood | R20, 1990, Waverley Park |
| 11.2 | Jason Dunstall | Collingwood | R16, 1989, Princes Park |
| 11.2 | Leigh Matthews | Melbourne | R1, 1981, M.C.G. |
| 11.2 | Peter Hudson | Footscray | R16, 1970, Waverley Park |
| 11.2 | Peter Hudson | Fitzroy | R22, 1970, Junction Oval |
[