| Most Goals in a Game |
|---|
| Goals | Player | Opponent | Game |
|---|
| 5 | Roy Park | Carlton | R12, 1914, Princes Park |
| 5 | Roy Park | St Kilda | R3, 1913, M.C.G. |
| 5 | Roy Park | Carlton | R5, 1913, M.C.G. |
| 5 | Roy Park | South Melbourne | R8, 1913, M.C.G. |
| 5 | Roy Park | Collingwood | R15, 1913, Victoria Park |
| 5 | Roy Park | Richmond | R18, 1913, Punt Rd |
| 5 | Roy Park | Fitzroy | R14, 1912, M.C.G. |
| 5 | Dave Cumming | Geelong | R18, 1911, M.C.G. |
| 5 | Bert Hartkopf | Geelong | R14, 1909, Corio Oval |
| 5 | Martin Ratz | Geelong | R17, 1908, East Melbourne |
| 4 | Roy Park | Carlton | R3, 1914, M.C.G. |
| 4 | Roy Park | Geelong | R4, 1914, M.C.G. |
| 4 | Roy Park | Melbourne | R2, 1913, M.C.G. |
| 4 | Roy Park | Essendon | R7, 1913, East Melbourne |
| 4 | Roy Park | St Kilda | R12, 1913, Junction Oval |
| 4 | Roy Park | South Melbourne | R17, 1913, Lake Oval |
| 4 | Dave Cumming | Essendon | R10, 1912, M.C.G. |
| 4 | Roy Park | Carlton | R18, 1912, Princes Park |
| 4 | Bert Hartkopf | Geelong | R9, 1911, Corio Oval |
| 4 | Martin Ratz | Geelong | R4, 1910, Corio Oval |
| 4 | Martin Ratz | Fitzroy | R7, 1910, East Melbourne |
| 4 | Pat Morrissey | Essendon | R11, 1910, East Melbourne |
| 4 | Bert Hartkopf | Richmond | R12, 1910, Punt Rd |
| 4 | Edgar Kneen | Richmond | R12, 1910, Punt Rd |
| 4 | Bert Hartkopf | Geelong | R13, 1910, East Melbourne |
| 4 | Bert Hartkopf | Essendon | R4, 1909, East Melbourne |
| 4 | Frank Boynton | Fitzroy | R9, 1909, East Melbourne |
| 4 | Bert Hartkopf | St Kilda | R12, 1909, East Melbourne |
| 4 | Martin Ratz | Richmond | R2, 1908, East Melbourne |
| 4 | Edgar Kneen | South Melbourne | R14, 1908, East Melbourne |
| 4 | Bert Hartkopf | Fitzroy | R16, 1908, Brunswick St |
[